Although We Exercise Free Will and Generate Karma, Results Ultimately Depend on God’s Will?

Question

In Chapter 10 of God Talks with Arjuna: The Bhagavad Gita, page 2325, Paramahansa Yogananda discusses the interplay between predestination and free will, explaining that man, as a microcosmic creator, influences the future through his actions. However, their fruits are dispensed by God according to His just law of compensation. Does this imply that although we exercise free will and generate karma, its results ultimately depend on God’s will and sanction, such that no result can manifest without

—Sreevin, India

Answer

Dear Sreevin,

The law of karma is exacting and precise. The scope of our free will is circumscribed by our past actions. The only true free will we possess is to turn inward to God-contact and divine will or to remain in the narrow box of ego-impulses. Why do we like “samosa” or “sambar?” Because we have been raised with it. An American will want donuts or pancakes or a hamburger. So where’s the free will in such choices? You see? We think we make the choice but our choices are very narrowly defined by circumstance, meaning “karma.” However: “karma is grace, and grace is karma.” Karma is the gateway to freedom. By accepting what is ours to deal with in life and performing our rightful duties with non-attachment (nishkam karma) and offering it to God for guidance and as a free-will gift of love, we are gradually freed from all karma. God has no karma for having created the world. Our soul, the great Atman, has no karma, made in the image of God since eternity.

It is not God’s will or sanction that we are dependent upon. It is our own free-will choice to transcend ego desires and subconscious impulses and seek the transcendent, immortal, ever-free state of our soul. That is really the only free will we possess, at least in practical, karmic terms. God doesn’t really care if we eat idlii or a donut. God seeks only our attention; out interest; our love; our desire to know, love and serve Him. The rest is mostly details. Some actions point us to God others to ego-bondage. In that sense, then it is better to pray than to drink alcohol. But only because right action (sattwic in nature) points us upward to God-realization. After enlightenment we are not touched karmically speaking by actions although a sage is counseled always to give a good example and naturally is inclined to perform right actions for the benefit of others. If there is no ego how can there be karma?

This is a very deep subject, my friend. For most of us, it is better to focus on right action, nishkam karma: offering “even a leaf” to God as Krishna or whomever and perform our karma-God-given duties without attachment in an act of devotion. The hair-splitting aspects of karma can drive us crazy imagining we can know the mind of God. When you know God, He can reveal all to you. By the practice of Kriya Yoga, we use the body’s own functions to transcend the “natural turbulence” of the mind to reach the equilibrium state described by Patanjali in Verse 2, Pada 1 of the Yoga Sutras: “yogas chitta vritti nirodha.”

May the light of your soul guide you to the “promised land” of moksha!

Nayaswami Hriman