How to Reconcile Christianity’s Non-Belief in Reincarnation with Hinduism’s Belief in It?

Question

monotheistic religions like Christianity reject the idea of reincarnation, whereas Hinduism and Buddhism believe in rebirth. How does Ananda’s path reconcile these fundamentally different beliefs?

—Gayatri, India

Answer

Dear Gayatri,

Your question runs to the nexus, the crossroads of East and West. Reincarnation offers the one thing that can rescue Christianity from the box it finds itself in for its belief in eternal damnation and Jesus Christ as the only savior of humanity. Ananda is inspired by and dedicated to the teachings of Paramhansa Yogananda: a great sat guru from India (as you know). He represents the great tradition of Sanantan Dharma whose precepts include reincarnation. In Chapter 35 of his now famous Autobiography of a Yogi, Yogananda points out some key passages in the Christian Bible that point to the acceptance of reincarnation. But then why and how was this teaching rejected?

I have written a book addressing your question, incidentally! “The Once and Future Christ” (by Nayaswami Hriman McGilloway). Based on Yogananda’s wisdom and insights, I believe that a time will come in the future when more and more Christians will discover reincarnation and the acceptance of many other world teachers (saviors) by the very force of truth itself. It won’t come from a Pope or a Christian saint as there are just too many Christian churches and sects that are hopelessly divided. It will come from the rising awareness and deep sincerity of countless Christians who have been exposed to Sanatan Dharma in various ways.

Reincarnation is true but so also is the concept of one-life: for after death virtually all the details of the body, personality and life we’ve just led vanish into the ether never to be re-lived; each life is unique. So long as a person believes in an after-life but with only one-life to lead, there is no choice but to see the after-life as eternal whether “hell” or “heaven.” Only in enlightenment will the soul be able to look back and see the great drama of countless lives and say, “What a good show (lila) it has been.” None of these lives and these countless details and relationships have a reality apart from Oneness in God. Until we achieve God-realization, nothing is real and nothing makes any sense. In God we see all things as God playing all the parts.

That day has not arrived and is probably still very far off in time and space. But it is coming. The ranks of Christians questioning the limiting beliefs of orthodox faith is growing. Rejoice. “The truth shall make you free.”

Nayaswami Hriman