Spiritual Success and Material Success

Question

Is spiritual success incomplete without material success?
If one is blessed with an immense talent and opportunities by God in a form of say art or sports, but gives it up to meditate on God, is it a sin against God? Had Albert Einstein or Beethoven spent their lives meditating, pilgrimages and on spiritual discourses, would they have been unfair to their natural talent? The highest form of earthly accomplishments often need extreme practice, devotion and focus. So how to balance?

—Sangita, India

Answer

Dear Sangita,

The karma of individual souls is infinitely varied. There is no absolute formula for predicting karma.

Nonetheless: spiritual success (aka moksha) requires far more commitment, energy and grace than material success. And, material success is not a prerequisite for spiritual success.

Nonetheless, in the broad picture of countless lifetimes, material success is a good preparation for spiritual success even if not required.

There’s another reason, although (again) not absolute. We have to work out at least some of our karma before achieving the early stage of liberation (“jivan mukta“). This can mean, for some people, that achieving material desires including success, fame and status may be needed before the soul realizes that these goals cannot bring lasting happiness.

If Einstein had been inspired to seek God instead of the secrets of the universe, that would normally be the higher dharma: hence: “When a higher dharma conflicts with a lower dharma, the higher dharma should be followed.”

But what if Einstein was motivated, even in part, perhaps by unwillingness or indifference, to escape his scientific karma/dharma. If so, then I would guess that his spiritual success might have been thwarted. But not necessarily so.

In the Gita, Krishna promises the devotee that He will make “good your deficiencies and render permanent your gains.”

Elsewhere Krishna assures us that no spiritual effort is ever lost.

A devotee must be careful not to justify his unwillingness to accept his duties in life by running away to a strictly spiritual life. This was almost the norm in past centuries and it has spawned in our times many souls with unfulfilled desires. We see this all around us.

Paramhansa Yogananda taught, however, that our era is one in which the balanced path of moderation is best: fulfilling one’s duties while also seeking God especially through daily meditation and selfless action.

So, in principal, I would like to say that one can do both: reveal the secrets of the universe while achieving God communion!

Blessings to you, friend!
Nayaswami Hriman