Why Do Good People Suffer? Why Do Selfish People Have Success?

Question

Namaste Guruji,
Why do people who believe in God, who always do good to people, who are absolutely selfless and full of love, go through a lot of suffering, whereas for people who are selfish and greedy and never have good intention towards people live the most beautiful life, full of opportunities and always having good luck? I really hope my question gets answered because I've been dying to know. Thankyou.

—Ridenla, India

Answer

Dear Ridenla,

I do sincerely hope you don’t have to “die to know” but (chuckle) step back and let us admit that while you have a good point, life is not quite that simple in black and white. Bad things also happen to bad people, after all! It’s just that they expect that to happen because on some level they know they have been naughty while good people have the expectation of reward for their goodness. I understand that.

Let’s, then, examine the dilemma we face and that you so wisely unveil on behalf of all humanity! Here are some thoughts:

  1. Goodness born of conscious intention by the ego is still binding. It creates karma tied to the sense of ego-self. While “good” karma (actions) are better than “bad” actions and while good actions bring benefits of calmness and harmony, the soul has no ego. The soul is eternal and transcendent of action, whether good or bad. The soul eschews therefore action motivated by even the wise ego because the soul knows that the Doer of all action is the true Self, Brahma. Krishna in the Bhagavad Gita exhorts us to practice nishkam karma: action without expectation or desire for the results; action motivated by the promptings of the soul, not the ego. However, this can take lifetimes.
  2. First we learn yama: avoidance of wrong action.
  3. Then we learn niyama: what is right action.
  4. Then we offer all action, good and bad, to God without attachment to results. Even when we err, we “give it God” who has created maya to test us whether we prefer maya or seek God alone.
  5. Then we pray to be an instrument of God, attuning our will to the Divine Will.
  6. Then we pray to do only the will of God in all things.
  7. Then God becomes the Doer.
  8. We all have “bad” karma to work out. Partly we work out bad karma by performing good karma.
  9. But we also work out bad karma by being tested when bad things happen to us when it seems like we have become good people. Like Job in the Christian Old Testament, we ask “Why am I being tested” (Just as YOU are asking the same question). When tested, do we retain our faith in God; do we remain even-minded and accepting of the Divine Will, or of our own karma? Do we challenge God’s justice when “bad things happen to good people?”
  10. In order to achieve liberation, we must transcend the separate “I” of ego altogether. Like Lahiri Mahasaya, the Divine Kitten, we yield to the prompting of the Atman, the soul, in the flow of Brahmacharya: the flow of divine grace.

My teacher, Swami Kriyananda, long ago instructed the monks in his care by saying: “Life is not fair (to the ego).” Do not expect to understand but seek “the peace which surpasseth all understanding.” (Here peace is the even-mindedness that needs no rational explanation but lives in the vibration of God, of Aum, of Divine Mother.)

Blessings,
Nayaswami Hriman