Why Is God Sometimes Portrayed as Jealous and Vengeful?

Question

I don’t understand the anger, jealousy of God in the old testament. He “remembers” people as if he had forgotten about them and is vengeful, wanting to kill off groups of people. It does not line up with “thou shall not kill, or covet” or forgive 70 times 7. It seems God is reacting out of insecurities. Some theologians believe that it’s a misinterpretation of the word “God” in some places, and that it was actually powerful beings from other planets ruling over earth people, rather than God.

—Gabrielle Porter, Australia

Answer

Dear Gabrielle,

Yes, I’ve read all those explanations myself. There’s an excellent book, The History of God, by Karen Armstrong. You might appreciate learning about the evolution of human concepts and definitions about God in the three Abrahamic faiths.

Rest assured, however, that it is useful to distinguish between whatever “God” is and the law of karma. The law of karma (“as you sow, so shall you reap”; or “do unto others….”) is exact and precise though love transcends all. (“Her sins, which are many, are forgiven for she has loved much.”)

Whether the law of karma is expressed as God being the Doer or we, the recipients of karma, are the provocateur of our own karma, the difference isn’t all that great because for the universe to function action and reaction (law of karma) must function or, well, the universe won’t function!

So one can say that God “punishes” because God is the “creator” of the laws of the universe, but in truth we punish ourselves because we inherit an echo of the divine creative impulse to make choices but our choices are masked by the world of appearances: again a necessary aspect of a functioning universe.

But for many people it is very hard to accept that, let us say, a child earned the karma of an early death or some terrible trauma. However, some of the greatest heroes of humanity in religion, art, science and humanitarian deeds, are those who have endured the greatest suffering or disadvantages. ” Without demanding to know the “why” of everything, we do say that “Whatever doesn’t kill you can make you stronger.”

Imagine a world that was perfect. Can you? Would you even know it was perfect if no illness, old age, death or other suffering existed? You couldn’t, any more than a fish probably thinks “I’m in water.” Without challenges we would never ask the important questions; never seek to improve our lives.

So the “jealousy” of God is more or less a metaphor for the existence of jealousy as part of the human drama. “God” is shown as acting out because it is WE who act out such emotions. We are part of God for everything that exists, good or bad, has its source in God-consciousness, though God is neither good nor bad in our relative sense. Only in the duality of creation do we see good and bad but in the transcendent state of the soul (God-consciousness) “I am that I am.”

Life is a nightmare without God-contact; at best life is uncertain, temporary and unpredictable. With inner certitude of I AM we learn to weather the storms of delusion and the sunshine of success as equal and necessary parts of the great drama. We are born to overcome; to pierce this veil of appearances to know the One who plays all the parts. That “jealous” God is a projection of our own jealousies.

Be at peace!
Nayaswami Hriman